Short Answer
A CIS umbrella company employs construction workers and pays them through PAYE as employees. Since 6 April 2026, recruitment agencies are responsible for making sure PAYE is paid correctly when they use an umbrella.
Paid Through
PAYE
Agency Liability From
6 April 2026
CIS Applies
No
How They Work
The umbrella invoices the agency or contractor, takes its fee and employer costs, and pays you a salary through PAYE. You are an employee of the umbrella, not self-employed, so CIS deductions should not apply.
The April 2026 Change
From 6 April 2026, the agency that supplies a worker, or the end client if there is no agency, is responsible for PAYE when an umbrella fails to pay it. This targets non-compliant umbrellas.
Need Help With This?
Our accountants can look at your own situation and sort it out with HMRC for you.
Warning Signs
- Take-home pay that looks too good compared with normal PAYE
- Part of your pay described as a loan or non-taxable payment
- No clear payslip showing tax and National Insurance
CIS Self-Employment vs an Umbrella
| CIS subcontractor | Umbrella employee | |
|---|---|---|
| Tax deducted | 20% or 30% CIS deduction | PAYE Income Tax and National Insurance |
| Tax return | Self Assessment needed | Usually not needed |
| Expenses | Allowable business expenses claimed | Very limited |
| Holiday pay and pension | No | Yes |
| Employment rights | No | Yes |
What to Check Before Signing Up
- You receive a Key Information Document showing how your pay is worked out
- Payslips show tax, National Insurance, the umbrella's margin and holiday pay clearly
- The umbrella's margin is a fixed weekly or monthly fee you can see
- It is accredited by a recognised body such as the Freelancer and Contractor Services Association or Professional Passport
- Your net pay is in line with normal PAYE for your gross pay
If You Are Offered Pay That Looks Too Good
Schemes that pay most of your money as a loan, bonus or other non-taxable payment are tax avoidance. HMRC can chase you personally for the unpaid tax, often years later, as well as the agency and umbrella. If take-home pay is far above what a standard tax calculation suggests, walk away.
Moving From CIS to an Umbrella
If you move from CIS self-employment to an umbrella during the tax year, you still file a Self Assessment return for the self-employed part of the year and claim back any CIS overpaid.
Worked Example: Comparing Take-Home
A bricklayer earns £40,000 a year in labour as a CIS subcontractor with £4,000 of expenses. His profit is £36,000, giving Income Tax of £4,686 and Class 4 National Insurance of £1,405.80, about £29,908 kept. Through an umbrella on the same £40,000 assignment rate, employer National Insurance, the umbrella margin and holiday pay all come out of the rate first, so take-home is usually lower. In return, he gets holiday pay, pension contributions and employment rights.
Questions to Ask the Agency
- Is the role genuinely self-employed, or under supervision and control?
- Which umbrellas are on your approved list?
- Is the rate quoted including or excluding employer costs?
- Who carries the PAYE liability if the umbrella fails to pay?
Your Rights as an Umbrella Employee
Umbrella employees are entitled to the National Minimum Wage, statutory sick pay, holiday pay and auto-enrolment into a pension. If an umbrella fails to pay these, you can raise it with the umbrella and the agency, and contact the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service (Acas) for help.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be under CIS and use an umbrella?
Not for the same work. If an umbrella employs you, you are paid through PAYE.
Why does my agency want me to use an umbrella?
Often because the work is under supervision and control, which makes self-employment risky for the agency. The umbrella employs you so PAYE is run correctly.
Can I still claim travel expenses through an umbrella?
Usually not. Since April 2016, workers under supervision, direction or control through an umbrella generally cannot claim tax relief on travel and subsistence.
Are CIS umbrellas legal?
Compliant umbrellas that run PAYE correctly are legal. Schemes that disguise pay as loans or other non-taxable payments are tax avoidance.
Will the April 2026 changes affect my pay?
Not if your umbrella was already compliant. The change shifts responsibility for unpaid PAYE onto agencies.
This guide gives general information based on HMRC rules for the 2026/27 tax year. Your own position may differ, so speak to an accountant before acting on it. Sources: GOV.UK: Umbrella company market guidance.