Contractor Guide

IR35 Status and the CEST Tool: How Your Status Is Decided

Written by Saurabh Bedi, FCCA ยท Updated 17 November 2026

Short Answer

Your IR35 status depends on whether you would be an employee if you were engaged directly. Medium and large clients must decide it and give you a status determination statement. HMRC's CEST tool can help, but it does not cover mutuality of obligation.

Decided By

Medium or Large Client

Disagreement Response

45 Days

HMRC Tool

CEST

Who Decides Your Status

If your client is a medium or large private company, or a public body, the client decides your status. If the client is small, your own limited company decides. See the small company exemption.

What the Tests Look At

  • Control: Who decides how, when and where you work
  • Substitution: Whether you can send someone else in your place
  • Mutuality of obligation: Whether the client must offer work and you must accept it
  • Financial risk and whether you act like a business

Unsure About Your IR35 Status?

We review contracts and working practices and help you respond to your client.

Get In Touch

HMRC's CEST Tool

CEST (Check Employment Status for Tax) asks about the engagement and gives a result. HMRC says it will stand by a result if the answers are accurate. Many advisers point out that it does not test mutuality of obligation properly, so treat it as one input, not the final word.

If You Disagree

Ask your client to review using their disagreement process. They must respond within 45 days with their decision and reasons. Read our guide to the status determination statement.

The Tests in Practice

FactorPoints towards outside IR35Points towards inside IR35
ControlYou decide how and when to do the workA manager directs your daily tasks and hours
SubstitutionYou can send a qualified substitute and pay themOnly you can do the work
Mutuality of obligationFixed project, no duty to offer or accept moreRolling work offered and expected to be accepted
Financial riskYou fix mistakes at your own cost, quote fixed pricesPaid by the day whatever happens
Part of the organisationTreated as an outside supplierStaff email signature, team meetings, appraisals

What Inside or Outside Means for Your Pay

Inside IR35Outside IR35
Who deducts taxThe fee-payer through PAYEYour company pays Corporation Tax; you pay personal tax
National InsuranceEmployee and employer National InsuranceOnly on the salary you take
How you take moneyTreated as employment incomeSalary and dividends
ExpensesVery limitedNormal business expenses

An IR35 calculator shows the take-home difference for your day rate.

Using CEST Well

1

Answer for the role as it really works, not as the contract says it should.

2

Save or print the result and its reference number.

3

Keep the answers with your contract and evidence of working practices.

4

Run it again if the role changes, such as new duties or a new manager.

HMRC says it will stand by a CEST result if the information given is accurate and the tool was not used as part of a scheme.

When CEST Gives No Result

Sometimes CEST says it cannot decide. That means your case is borderline, and the client or your company needs to weigh up all the factors, ideally with professional advice.

Mutuality of Obligation Explained

Mutuality of obligation means the client must offer work and you must accept it. Without it, there is no employment contract. CEST assumes it exists in every engagement, which is why many advisers say CEST leans towards inside IR35 results. Tribunals still consider it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the CEST tool legally binding?

No. It is a guide. Your status depends on the full facts of the engagement.

Does a contract decide IR35?

No. Working practices matter as much as the written contract. See IR35 compliant contracts.

Can I use CEST without giving my name?

Yes. CEST does not ask for your name or keep your details, so you can use it anonymously.

Does one inside IR35 contract affect my other contracts?

No. Each engagement is assessed on its own facts.

This guide gives general information based on HMRC rules for the 2026/27 tax year. Your own position may differ, so speak to an accountant before acting on it. Sources: GOV.UK: Off-payroll working rules (IR35), ESM10000.

Book A Free Quote