Short Answer
No contract can make you outside IR35 on its own. A contract helps when it reflects how you really work, with a genuine right of substitution, no client control over how you work, and no obligation to offer or accept more work.
Contract Alone
Not Enough
Key Factor
Working Practices
Decision Maker
Usually the Client
Clauses That Matter
- A real right to send a substitute
- You decide how the work is done
- Payment for deliverables or a project, not just time
- No obligation to accept further work
- You supply your own equipment and carry business risk
Working Practices Count Most
HMRC and tribunals look at what actually happens. If the contract allows substitution but you have never been allowed to use one, the clause carries little weight.
Unsure About Your IR35 Status?
We review contracts and working practices and help you respond to your client.
Keep Evidence
- Emails showing you set your own approach
- Proof of other clients and business costs
- Records of any substitutes used
Red Flags in a Contract
- Fixed working hours set by the client
- A named line manager who approves your work
- Paid holiday or sick pay
- Notice periods like an employee's
- Duties described as a job role rather than deliverables
- Use of the client's equipment and email as standard
Example: Same Contract, Different Outcome
Two developers sign identical contracts with a right of substitution and fixed deliverables. One works remotely, picks his own methods and has once sent a colleague in his place. The other sits in the client's team, follows daily stand-ups set by a manager and is told his substitute would not be accepted. The first is likely outside IR35. The second is likely inside, despite the same contract.
Steps to Strengthen Your Position
Ask for a contract review that also covers working practices.
Agree a statement of work with clear deliverables.
Invoice for milestones, not hours, where possible.
Keep a file of evidence for each engagement.
Ask the client to confirm its status decision in a status determination statement.
Insurance
Some contractors buy tax investigation insurance, which pays professional fees if HMRC opens an enquiry. It does not pay any tax found to be due.
A Practical Checklist
| Question | Strong answer for outside IR35 |
|---|---|
| Can you send a substitute? | Yes, and the client has no right to refuse a qualified one |
| Who decides how the work is done? | You, within the agreed deliverables |
| How are you paid? | By milestone or fixed price |
| Must you accept further work? | No |
| Do you use your own equipment? | Yes |
| Do you have other clients? | Yes, or you market your services to others |
Documents to Keep for Each Contract
- The signed contract and statement of work
- The status determination statement, if the client is medium or large
- Your CEST result and the answers you gave
- Emails showing how work was agreed and delivered
- Invoices and proof of business expenses
When to Get a New Review
Ask for a fresh review if your role expands, you move into a team management position, the client changes how it works with you, or the contract is extended for a long period. Status can change during an engagement.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will a contract review protect me from HMRC?
It reduces risk, but your status depends on the whole picture, including how you work day to day.
Is a substitution clause enough to be outside IR35?
No. It only helps if the right is real and the client would accept a qualified substitute.
Should I sign a contract that says I am inside IR35?
That depends on your rate and goals. If you believe the decision is wrong, challenge it before signing or use the client's disagreement process.
Do template contracts work?
They can be a starting point, but they need to reflect your actual role. A generic outside IR35 template carries little weight if your working practices say otherwise.
Should my contract mention IR35?
It can include the status decision and how disagreements are handled, but the decision itself comes from the facts.
This guide gives general information based on HMRC rules for the 2026/27 tax year. Your own position may differ, so speak to an accountant before acting on it. Sources: GOV.UK: Off-payroll working rules (IR35), ESM10000.